As someone who has done gold parties, and used goldfellow in the begining- while they didn't ever scam me or steal from me- their pricing is very low. They post on their website today that they are paying $14.69 per pennyweight for 14K. MANY websites are paying lower, but MANY legitimate websites are paying more in the $17.00-$18.00 range. On top of that- most top level jewelry stores- if you do your homework will pay you more in your local area. I just sold some 14K to a local jeweler for $22 a pennyweight! I have learned, sending Gold over the internet to anyone doesn't make a whole lot of sense because, if you call around locally, you can get more- quite quickly. Goodfellow is better than cash4gold who are absolutely ripping people with their pricing, but it makes no sense to sell to goldfellow as they are paying less than you can get elsewhere. That's the bottom line I would think- how much can you get payed for your gold. Do a little research, wherever you are, and you can get much more selling it locally or to other places...

My other complaint about this website and others though- is everyone claims to be the highest paying buyer in the country-- none of them are...

Goldfellow.com - STAY AWAY!!! I had originally sent my items in to them with the intention to get some extra cash for the holidays to buy my kids some presents. I printed my free FedEx label and immediately sent my jewelry in. Their tracking system was not real time! When I first called about my jewelry they did not have an answer to even where it was, let alone the “settlement amount”!1! After waiting over a week, and several unanswered calls I finally got a settlement amount from them and it was absolutely ridicolous! They pay top dollar? Complete BS! I immediately called them up and nicely asked why my amount was so little. They put a very rude male “supervisor” on the phone and I demanded my pak back! I finally received my jewelry back after fighting with them and them not even knowing where it was after 15 days! Never again!!! I got 3x the amount of money from my jewelry from my local pawn shop!! I have reported them to the BBB!!! That was the most aggravating thing that I have ever had to deal with in my life!!!