1/4/2010
To Whom It May Concern:
As a former loyal Sears customer, I would like to express my disappointment in the service I recently received by your company over the past month. On the morning of 12/4/2010 I had a flat tire, because I had originally purchased the tires from Sears I decided to take my car to the Sears Auto Center located at 2300 Tyrone Blvd. N. St. Petersburg, FL 33710. I spoke with the sales associate and told him about my tire and requested that the problem be fixed and my car serviced (oil change and standard fluids). He told me that they would check out the issue and get back to me via cell phone as to the problem.
I left my car at your Auto Center for well over 4 hours, ample time for the technician to address my issue and service my vehicle (oil change and standard fluids). When I returned I was informed that the issue was a nail puncture and that they removed it and patched the tire.
Later that evening I noticed that the tire that was patched, the front passenger side tire, was flat again. The next morning I took my car back to the same Sears so that your business could rectify the problem immediately. I originally brought my car to Sears on the 4th because I had a long period of time that I could leave it but on the 5th I was extremely pressed for time. After extolling my frustration about having to return the second day, the associate assured me that my car would be diagnosed and ready to go in 30 minutes. I left my car and went to grab a quick breakfast.
When I returned 30 minutes later my car was not finished. The technician did not call me even though he had my cell phone number to tell me that it was going to take longer than 30 minutes nor did he call me to let me know the real issue was with my tire.
The issue was not a nail at all; in fact it was that the tire was cracking. The technician explained that it was a factory defect and was partially covered under warranty, and that they had a new tire and could replace it for $80. With reluctance I agreed to the new tire and had to wait another 45 minutes to have a new tire installed, this process could’ve been started earlier if the associate just would’ve of called me while I was at breakfast rather than waiting for me to come back. As I drove away from the service center my washer fluid light came on which was supposed to be taken care of when I paid for the oil change and fluid services the previous day.
On Monday the 13th I drove from my home to work (approximately 35 miles). When I arrived at work I could hear air leaving my tire. I took my tire to the Sears Auto Center located nearest to my work at 599 Westshore Plaza, Tampa, Florida, hoping for better service than I had received at the Tyrone Mall location.
I informed the technician about my previous experience at Tyrone and what I was experiencing now with my tire. I asked him to remove all of the tires and check them for any cracks, defects, or punctures. I also asked him to top the washer fluid off since the other Sears Auto Center hadn’t done so. He assured me that the job would be done promptly and they would contact me when they had discovered what the problem was.
I had returned to work and after 2 ½ hours later I called the technician back. He said that they didn’t find anything with the tire or any of my tires. He told me that they took all of my tires off and put them in the dunk tank and nothing was wrong with them. I asked him to please check again because I could distinctly hear the unmistakable sound of air hissing from my tire.
He got back to me 3 hours later and said that nothing was wrong with the tires. I picked up my car and when I returned to work I noticed that my washer fluid light was still on and that I could still hear the tire hissing. When I left work that same evening, sure enough, my tire was flat again after being at your service center just hours before and the technician telling me there was nothing wrong with my tires. I had to pump my tire up and I took it to my local Toyota dealership. Both technicians there immediately heard the hissing from several feet away and took my vehicle.
The Toyota dealership called me the next day and told me that the tire would need to be replaced because there was excessive cracking. The tires that I had on my car were Goodyear tires exclusively sold at Sears. I called the Sears Auto Center that I took the car to the third time. I explained to the gentleman on the phone about my saga and how I needed a new tire. He did not apologize for the lack of customer service that I received from his store and proceeded to tell me that ordering the new tire would take a week and offered very little sympathy for my situation. I then called Goodyear directly to see if I could purchase a tire from them and they told me that only Sears could sell me that tire.
After becoming beyond frustrated I called the Toyota dealership back to see if I could just deal with them since Sears obviously did not want my business. After a deeper examination of my tires the dealership found that all three of my tires had cracks in them (see pictures attached). The technician told me that I would need to replace all of the tires.
I was also informed that if the Sears Auto Center took all of my tires off and examined them like they had claimed they would have noticed it right away. I am not only astonished by the service, lack of knowledge, and shear incompetency of the Sears technicians. It is apparent that honesty, fair business practices, and my safety is not a concern for Sears Auto Centers. In an effort to right this situation, I expect to be refunded for my brand new tire that I had to buy from the Sears at the Tyrone Mall. I would also like a formal apology for all of my time, frustration and money that I had to spend that shouldn’t have happened if the technicians would have done their job adequately.
I have always been a loyal customer and I never thought I would have to go through such an ordeal over tires and especially not with Sears. Please right the situation at hand.
Attached you will find the three receipts from the three different times I had to go to Sears. I have also included the information from the dealership on their findings.
I get a response from Sears auto center and they refund my tire. However, i mailed the letter with attached pictures the same day that i posted this on a comments page for Sears.
so then an email chain develops with me and a sear blue ribbon customer service guy who sucked. Sorry its long but please please do not buy anything from them
And we Thank You for being an absolutely wonderful customer and accepting the offered concession. Thank You for your loyalty to our company and you have a wonderful day as well.
Thank you,
Jacquese Calvert
Blue Ribbon Service Case Manager
888-266-4043 Ext 12
________________________________
Sent: Tue 2/1/2011 1:59 PM
To: Blueribbonservice2
Subject: Re: Sears Case 3464326
You also had my cell phone that you chose not to utilize. I really do not want to get into ethical debate with you or your company. Or discuss morality or safety for customers. Thank you for hard work on the gift card. I really do appreciate the efforts you have taken to ensure that I will continue to shop at Sears. I hope you have an absolutley wonderful day.
Take care and best of luck as an executive case manager.
________________________________
From: Blueribbonservice2 <
[email protected]>
Sent: Tue, February 1, 2011 1:45:44 PM
Subject: RE: Sears Case 3464326
I have provided you my contact information so that you are able to contact me at your convenience, it would not be ethical for me to contact you on your work phone with personal business and again I do apologize. We will process the gift card and it will be shipped to you ground mail within 7-10 business days, we will also provide you with a follow up call/e-mail to ensure that the gift card is received. If you have any additional questions or would like to speak with me further please contact me at your earliest convenience using the contact information below. We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience suffered and thank you for your business and feedback.
Thank You For Choosing Sears,
Jacquese Calvert
Blue Ribbon Service
Executive Case Manager Specialist
Sears Holdings Corporation
Phone: 888-266-4043 Ext. 12
Schedule: Monday - Friday 9am to 6pm
Email:
[email protected]
________________________________
Sent: Mon 1/31/2011 3:23 PM
To: Blueribbonservice2
Subject: Re: Sears Case 3464326
You have my phone number to call me. You never called me. Send me the $50.00. I guess that is what you feel is sufficient for everything that you caused me including not taking my safety seriously. I will make sure that when I do my promo for the Toyota Dealership and how well they took care of me, I'll be sure to mention the wondeful gift card.
Thank you for effort, time and overall service.
Sincerely,
- a loyal sears customer.
________________________________
From: Blueribbonservice2 <
[email protected]>
Sent: Mon, January 31, 2011 3:57:35 PM
Subject: RE: Sears Case 3464326
I have checked the letter that you have sent to our company and it does not say that you were refunded, it does state, and I quote "I have always been a loyal customer and I never thought I would have to go through such an ordeal over tires and especially not with Sears. Please right the situation at hand" which led me to believe that you had not been refunded and needed further assistance addressing your concern. We appreciate you taking the time out to provide this feedback and it has been forwarded to the appropriate channels, I do understand that you will no longer visit our Auto Center however I would like to know if you would continue shopping Sears Retail. We would be more then happy to provide you with a $50.00 gift card if you would like to continue shopping with our company.
Thank You,
Jacquese Calvert
Blue Ribbon Service
Executive Case Manager Specialist
Sears Holdings Corporation
Phone: 888-266-4043 Ext. 12
Schedule: Monday - Friday 9am to 6pm
Email:
[email protected]
________________________________
Sent: Mon 1/31/2011 10:57 AM
To: Blueribbonservice2
Subject: Re: Sears Case 3464326
Jacquese,
You are furthering my view that Sears is an inept and incompetent organization. If you check your records, I have already been issued a refund for the tire. The point of the letter wasn't to get a refund, I expected that getting my money back was the least that you were going to do. Instead the point of the letter was more to let you know the ordeal that I had to endure with your company which resulted in the refund of my tire, a lost sale for you, wasted time for me, and severed customer loyalty.
________________________________
From: Blueribbonservice2 <
[email protected]>
Sent: Mon, January 31, 2011 11:25:13 AM
Subject: RE: Sears Case 3464326
I have reviewed your letter and it is my understanding that you are requesting a $80.00 refund for a tire that was replaced due to a manufactures defect, am I correct in my assumption? If I am not please briefly explain your concern so that I am able to address it accordingly.
Thank You,
Jacquese Calvert
Blue Ribbon Service
Executive Case Manager Specialist
Sears Holdings Corporation
Phone: 888-266-4043 Ext. 12
Schedule: Monday - Friday 9am to 6pm
Email:
[email protected]
<mailto:
[email protected]>
________________________________
Sent: Thu 1/27/2011 1:00 PM
To: Blueribbonservice2
Subject: Re: Sears Case 3464326
from 9-5 you can reach me at 813.288.1800 ext. 222. after that you can try my cell phone 727-688-6037.
________________________________
From: Blueribbonservice2 <
[email protected]>
Sent: Thu, January 27, 2011 1:36:01 PM
Subject: Sears Case 3464326
Thank You for writing in regards to your recent concern with our Auto Center. I would like to speak with you regarding your concern however I do not having a working home phone number on file. Please contact me at your earliest convenience so that I am able to assist you additionally, I look forward to speaking with you.
Thank You,
Jacquese Calvert
Blue Ribbon Service
Executive Case Manager Specialist
Sears Holdings Corporation
Phone: 888-266-4043 Ext. 12
Schedule: Monday - Friday 9am to 6pm
Email:
[email protected]